Modeling Earth’s Surface

Lesson Objectives

  • Describe what information a map can convey.
  • Identify some major types of map projections and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each.
  • Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of using a globe.

Introduction

Different representations of Earth’s surface are valuable for different purposes. Accuracy, scale, portability, and features represented are among the many factors that determine which representation is most useful.

Globe

Earth is best represented by a globe because Earth is a sphere, as seen in the Figure below. Sizes and shapes of features are not distorted and distances are true to scale.
external image images?id=309138
A globe is the most accurate way to represent Earth's curved surface.
Globes usually have a geographic coordinate system and a scale. The shortest distance between two points is the length of the arc (portion of a circle) that connects them.
Math problem: How would you measure the distance between two points on a globe in miles?
  • Here’s an idea: Pull a string taut between the two locations and mark both locations. Lay the string on the equator of the globe. Count the number of degrees between the marks, starting with one end at 0. The number of miles per degree at the equator is 69.17; now multiply the number of degrees by that number to get the distance in miles between the two locations.
A location on a globe must be determined using polar oordinates because a globe is curved.
Example of polar coordinates.
Example of polar coordinates.

The polar coordinate system is useful for curved surfaces.
Globes are difficult to make and carry around and they cannot be enlarged to show the details of any particular area and, as a result, people need maps.

Maps as Models

A map is a visual representation of a surface, with symbols indicating important features. Different types of maps contain different information. Examples of some of the maps that are important in Earth science are:
  • Relief maps use color to show elevations of larger areas (Figure above).
  • Radar maps topography (Figure above) or weather. National Weather Service Doppler Radar maps are found here: http://radar.weather.gov/.
  • Satellite-view maps show terrains and vegetation, such as forests, deserts, and mountains (Figure above).
  • Climate maps show average temperatures and rainfall. Climate maps from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration are found here: http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/psd/data/usclimate/states.fast.html.
  • Weather maps show storms, air masses, and fronts. Weather maps, also from NOAA, are found here: http://www.nws.noaa.gov/.
  • Topographic maps show elevations using contour lines to reveal landforms (Figure below) .
  • Geologic maps detail the types and locations of rocks found in an area (Figure below).

Map Projections

Maps are 2-dimensional (2D) representations of a 3-dimensional (3D) Earth. In a small area Earth is essentially flat, so a flat map is accurate. But to represent a larger portion of Earth, map makers must use some type of projection to collapse the third dimension onto a flat surface. A projection is a way to represent the Earth’s curved surface on flat paper. One example of a projection is shown in the Figure below.
external image images?id=309110
A map projection translates Earth's curved surface onto two dimensions.
There are two basic methods for making projections:
  • The map maker “slices” the sphere in some way and unfolds it to make a flat map, like flattening out an orange peel.
  • The map maker looks at the sphere from a certain point and then translates this view onto a flat paper.
Let’s look at a few commonly used projections.

Mercator Projection

In 1569, Gerardus Mercator (1512-1594) developed the Mercator projection (seen in the Figure below). A flat piece of paper curves around the spherical Earth to make a cylinder. The paper touches the sphere at the equator, but the distance between the sphere and the paper increases toward the poles. The features of Earth’s surface are projected out onto the cylinder and then unrolled, creating a Mercator projection map.
A Mercator projection.
A Mercator projection.

A Mercator projection translates the curved surface of Earth onto a cylinder.
Where do you think a Mercator map is most accurate? Where is it least accurate? Near the equator the shapes and sizes of features are correct but features get stretched out near the poles. For example, on a globe, Greenland is fairly small but in a Mercator map, Greenland is stretched out to look almost as big the United States.
In a Mercator projection, all compass directions are straight lines, but a curved line is the shortest distance between the two points. Many world maps still use Mercator projection today. Early explorers found Mercator maps useful because they more frequently visited equatorial regions.
A good explanation of the distortion that results from the projection of a sphere onto a flat surface can be seen in Alternative World Maps: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cuuluAq4TtU&feature=related.

Conic Projection

A conic map projection uses a cone shape to better represent regions and best depicts the area where the cone touches the globe. Looking at the Figure below, what is the advantage of a conic projection over a Mercator projection?
Conic map projection of Earth.
Conic map projection of Earth.

A conic map projection wraps the Earth with a cone shape rather than a cylinder.

Gnomonic Projection

A gnomonic map projection is illustrated in the Figure below. With a gnomonic map projection, paper is placed on the area that you want to map. The projection is good for features near that point. The poles are often mapped this way.
Gnomonic projection of Earth.
Gnomonic projection of Earth.

A gnomonic projection places a flat piece of paper on a point somewhere on Earth and projects an image from that point.

Robinson Projection

In 1963, Arthur Robinson created an attractive map projection in which latitude lines are projected but meridians are curved, resulting in a map that is an ellipse rather than a rectangle (see the Figure below for an example). This projection has less distortion near the poles and features within 45 degrees of the equator are closer to their true dimensions. The distances along latitude lines are true, but the scales along each line of latitude are different. Robinson projections are still commonly used.
Robinson projection.
Robinson projection.

A Robinson projection more accurately reflects the size and shape of features near 45

Winkel Tripel Projection

The National Geographic Society uses the Winkel Tripel Projection, which uses mathematical formulas to create a map projection that is also distorted at the edges.
Winkel Tripel Projection.
Winkel Tripel Projection.

The Winkel Tripel Projection of Earth.
Locations on a map are determined using rectangular coordinates.
Rectangular coordinates example.
Rectangular coordinates example.

Rectangular coordinates are useful for flat surfaces.
Google Earth is a neat site to download to your computer: earth.google.com/download-earth.html. The maps on this site allow you to zoom in or out, look from above, tilt your image and lots more.

Lesson Summary

  • Maps and globes are models of the Earth’s surface.
  • Globes are the most accurate representations, because they are round like the Earth, but using a globe as a map has practical disadvantages.
  • There are many ways to project the three-dimensional surface of the Earth on to a flat map. Each type of map has some advantages as well as disadvantages.
  • Most maps use latitude and longitude to indicate locations.

Review Questions

  1. Which of the following gives you the most accurate representations of distances and shapes on the Earth’s surface?
    1. Mercator projection map
    2. Robinson projection map
    3. Globe
  2. Explain the difference between latitude and longitude.
  3. In what country are you located, if your coordinates are 60oN and 120oW?
  4. Which map projection is most useful for navigation, especially near the equator? Explain.
  5. In many cases, maps are more useful than a globe. Why?
  6. Which of the following map projections gives you the least distortion around the poles?
    1. Mercator projection map
    2. Robinson projection map
    3. Conic projection

Further Reading / Supplemental Links

Vocabulary

projection A way to represent a 3-dimensional surface in two dimensions. map A 2-dimensional representation of Earth's surface.

Points to Consider

  • Imagine you are a pilot and must fly from New York to Paris. Use a globe to determine the distance. Now do the same with a map. How are these activities the same and how are they different?
  • Would you choose a map that used a Mercator projection if you were going to explore Antarctica? What other type of map could you use?
  • Maps use a scale, which means a certain distance on the map equals a larger distance on Earth. Why are maps drawn to scale? What would be some problems you would have with a map that did not use a scale?

Maine Connections

Lesson Plans

Webquests

More Resources

Videos

Games